Skip to main content
Home
  • Connect!
  • Donate
  • My Account
  • Join/Login
  • S
  • Connect!
  • Join/Login
  • Home
  • About
    • What is Social and Personality Psychology?
    • Leadership
      • Elections
    • Get Involved
    • Committees
    • Diversity & Inclusion Initiatives
    • Government Relations
    • Governance Documents
    • Staff
    • Jobs at SPSP
      • Benefits of Working at SPSP
      • Current Openings
  • Members
    • Membership Categories and Rates
    • Member Demographics
    • Member Directory
    • Collaboration Zone
    • APA Division 8
    • Fellows
    • Listservs and Shared Interest Groups
    • Member Deals and Discounts
  • Publications
    • Best Practices
    • Publication Policies
    • Resources
    • PSPB
      • Editorial Philosophy
      • Manuscript Preparation/Submission Guidelines
      • PSPB Online
    • PSPR
      • Editorial Philosophy
      • Manuscript Preparation
      • PSPR Online
    • SPPS
      • Manuscript Preparation
      • SPPS Online
  • Events
    • 2022 Convention
    • Future/Past Conventions
    • Summer Psychology Forum
    • Society of Southeastern Social Psychologists
    • APA Convention (Division 8)
    • Student Opportunities
      • SISPP
      • SPUR
      • EASP
      • EAPP
    • Learning Online
  • Giving
    • Ways to Give
    • Planned Giving
    • Tribute Wall
    • Annual Reports
    • ARP Awards
  • Awards/Grants
    • Annual Awards
      • Senior Career Contribution Awards
      • Mid-Career Awards
      • Early Career Awards
      • Teaching and Mentoring Awards
      • Prizes for a Single Outstanding Contribution
      • Media Awards
      • Service Awards
      • Student Awards
      • Diversity Awards
    • Student Awards
      • Heritage Dissertation Research Award
      • Outstanding Research Award
      • Graduate Student Poster Award
      • Undergraduate Student Poster Award
      • Student Publication Prize
      • Jenessa Shapiro Graduate Research Award
      • Graduate Travel/Registration Award
      • Diversity Graduate Travel/Registration Award
      • Diversity Undergraduate Registration Award
    • Diversity Awards
      • Jenessa Shapiro Award for Contributions to Diversity and Inclusion
      • Jenessa Shapiro Graduate Research Award
      • Diversity Graduate Travel/Registration Award
      • Diversity Undergraduate Registration Award
    • Heritage Wall of Fame
    • International Awards
      • International Travel/Registration Award
      • International Bridge-Building Award
    • Legacy Program
    • Travel/Registration Awards
      • Graduate Travel/Registration Award
      • Diversity Graduate Travel/Registration Award
      • Diversity Undergraduate Registration Award
      • Teacher & Scholar Travel/Registration Award
      • International Travel/Registration Award
      • International Bridge-Building Award
    • Small Research Grant Program
    • Small Conference Grant Program
    • Community Catalyst Grant Program
  • News
    • Character and Context Blog
    • Member Updates
    • Press Releases
    • Member Newsletter
    • Student Newsletter
  • Resources
    • Connect!
    • Racism, Bias & Diversity
    • Free-Form Fridays
    • Students
      • Graduate Program Directory
      • Applying to Grad School
      • Life in Graduate School
    • Early Career
    • Primarily Undergraduate Institutions
    • Multimedia
      • #SPSPchat
      • SPSP Experts
      • Out of the Lab
      • Convention Videos
    • Funding
    • International Study and Work
    • Statistics & Data Analysis
    • Teaching
      • Recommended Textbooks
      • Syllabi Examples
      • Teaching Aids
      • Video
    • Applied Psychology
  • Careers
    • Find/Post a Job
    • Graduation Outcomes
    • Career Resources
    • Academic Job Market
    • Non-Academic Job Market
    • Undergraduate Research
  • Connect!
  • Join/Login
  • Home
  • About
    • What is Social and Personality Psychology?
    • Leadership
      • Elections
    • Get Involved
    • Committees
    • Diversity & Inclusion Initiatives
    • Government Relations
    • Governance Documents
    • Staff
    • Jobs at SPSP
      • Benefits of Working at SPSP
      • Current Openings
  • Members
    • Membership Categories and Rates
    • Member Demographics
    • Member Directory
    • Collaboration Zone
    • APA Division 8
    • Fellows
    • Listservs and Shared Interest Groups
    • Member Deals and Discounts
  • Publications
    • Best Practices
    • Publication Policies
    • Resources
    • PSPB
      • Editorial Philosophy
      • Manuscript Preparation/Submission Guidelines
      • PSPB Online
    • PSPR
      • Editorial Philosophy
      • Manuscript Preparation
      • PSPR Online
    • SPPS
      • Manuscript Preparation
      • SPPS Online
  • Events
    • 2022 Convention
    • Future/Past Conventions
    • Summer Psychology Forum
    • Society of Southeastern Social Psychologists
    • APA Convention (Division 8)
    • Student Opportunities
      • SISPP
      • SPUR
      • EASP
      • EAPP
    • Learning Online
  • Giving
    • Ways to Give
    • Planned Giving
    • Tribute Wall
    • Annual Reports
    • ARP Awards
  • Awards/Grants
    • Annual Awards
      • Senior Career Contribution Awards
      • Mid-Career Awards
      • Early Career Awards
      • Teaching and Mentoring Awards
      • Prizes for a Single Outstanding Contribution
      • Media Awards
      • Service Awards
      • Student Awards
      • Diversity Awards
    • Student Awards
      • Heritage Dissertation Research Award
      • Outstanding Research Award
      • Graduate Student Poster Award
      • Undergraduate Student Poster Award
      • Student Publication Prize
      • Jenessa Shapiro Graduate Research Award
      • Graduate Travel/Registration Award
      • Diversity Graduate Travel/Registration Award
      • Diversity Undergraduate Registration Award
    • Diversity Awards
      • Jenessa Shapiro Award for Contributions to Diversity and Inclusion
      • Jenessa Shapiro Graduate Research Award
      • Diversity Graduate Travel/Registration Award
      • Diversity Undergraduate Registration Award
    • Heritage Wall of Fame
    • International Awards
      • International Travel/Registration Award
      • International Bridge-Building Award
    • Legacy Program
    • Travel/Registration Awards
      • Graduate Travel/Registration Award
      • Diversity Graduate Travel/Registration Award
      • Diversity Undergraduate Registration Award
      • Teacher & Scholar Travel/Registration Award
      • International Travel/Registration Award
      • International Bridge-Building Award
    • Small Research Grant Program
    • Small Conference Grant Program
    • Community Catalyst Grant Program
  • News
    • Character and Context Blog
    • Member Updates
    • Press Releases
    • Member Newsletter
    • Student Newsletter
  • Resources
    • Connect!
    • Racism, Bias & Diversity
    • Free-Form Fridays
    • Students
      • Graduate Program Directory
      • Applying to Grad School
      • Life in Graduate School
    • Early Career
    • Primarily Undergraduate Institutions
    • Multimedia
      • #SPSPchat
      • SPSP Experts
      • Out of the Lab
      • Convention Videos
    • Funding
    • International Study and Work
    • Statistics & Data Analysis
    • Teaching
      • Recommended Textbooks
      • Syllabi Examples
      • Teaching Aids
      • Video
    • Applied Psychology
  • Careers
    • Find/Post a Job
    • Graduation Outcomes
    • Career Resources
    • Academic Job Market
    • Non-Academic Job Market
    • Undergraduate Research

You are here

Home » News » Character and Context Blog

Character  &  Context

The Science of Who We Are and How We Relate
Editors: Judith Hall, Leah Dickens, Colleen Sinclair

 

Jan 17, 2022

Improving Accuracy in Memory Recall: The Particular Case of Alibi Generation

by Hyungwook Yim and Simon Dennis
Senior woman thinking pensively

Imagine you are standing trial for a crime you didn’t commit. The prosecutor asks, “Where were you at 9pm on the night of the murder?” The night feels like ages ago, and you aren’t entirely sure. Giving your best guess, you guess wrong.

In 1985, Ronald Cotton had to provide an alibi for the night of a crime. However, being confused, he provided the place he was the week before the crime. This memory error was largely to blame for Cotton’s sentence of life plus 50 years in prison. It wasn’t until ten years later that Cotton was exonerated based on DNA evidence.

What made Cotton confused about where he was? Was it just an unlucky day, or is this a mistake that people can commonly make? And would there be a way to fix these errors, or at least help people make fewer mistakes?

Unfortunately, until recently, not many scientific studies have directly examined this important problem. This was mainly because it was hard to establish the ground truth when asking where people were. However, now, almost everybody carries a tracking device that allows researchers to know precisely where they were at any given time: a smartphone.

Relying on this modern convenience, my colleagues and I designed a study where participants used a smartphone app to record their daily whereabouts. The app automatically and continuously recorded (every 10 minutes) the participant’s location and also their environment (such as the sound and their movements). This recording happened for 4 weeks.

A week after the recording period, participants were tested on the accuracy of their memory. We gave the participants a Google Map with 4 location pins, and asked which pin showed where they were at a certain day and time. One pin was the actual location, while the other pins were randomly selected from places they visited during the 4-week period. Each participant received 72 test questions, which asked a location for a different day and time.

Overall, people were accurate 64% of the time, which was above the accuracy level if they randomly guessed (25%, four options). However, the interesting part was in the errors that the participants made, as they showed certain patterns.

How Did People Mis-Remember?

We saw three common mistakes. When the participants picked a wrong location pin, it tended to be geographically closer to the correct pin. They also wrongly picked location pins that had a similar environment (such as sound, movement) to the correct pin. Lastly, the wrongly picked locations were visited at a similar time to the correct location.

This last type of memory error regarding time is especially interesting, as it was shown in two ways. First, participants wrongly picked locations that they visited right before or after visiting the correct location. For example, if the correct location was the grocery store, when people made an error, it tended to be the location before or after visiting the grocery store (maybe a  coffee shop).

Second, participants wrongly picked locations that they visited on the same day of week, or at the same time of day as the correct locations. For example, when making an error, some participants wrongly chose a location that they visited on the same day of the week as the correct location (e.g., Monday), even though it was a week before. Others chose a location that was visited at the same time as the correct location (e.g., 5pm), even though it was not on the same day. These examples illustrate a type of error regarding the so-called ‘categorical time’ —and this error is exactly the one Cotton made. Our study supports that this is a common error everyone makes!  These results together show that people are most confused when trying to remember events that happened in a similar location, time, and/or environment.

Is There A Way To Avoid These Memory Errors?

Avoiding these memory errors is essential when the outcome has a critical consequence. Is there a way to decrease, if not perfectly avoid, cases like Ronald Cotton’s?

The results of our study provide some hints.

First, investigators such as police interrogators should be fully aware of these natural memory errors that people make. Second, it will also help if questioners check for possible memory errors by asking specific questions. For example, if the person said he was at the bar last Monday at 5pm, the investigator can ask whether it was not the week before last, or whether it was not Tuesday or Friday at 5pm, to find out whether he has a pattern of visiting that bar that could confuse his memory. We believe that these ‘right questions’ can help people with more accurate recall, and—in the case of crimes—produce more accurate alibis.

Faulty memory isn’t always a huge deal, but as the case of Ronald Cotton shows, it can be the difference between freedom and imprisonment.


For Further Reading

Dennis, S. J., Garrett, P., Yim, H., Hamm, J., Osth, A. F., Sreekumar, V., & Stone, B. (2019). Privacy versus open science. Behavior Research Methods, 51, 1839–1848. https://doi.org/10.3758/s13428-019-01259-5

Laliberte, E., Yim, H., Stone, B., & Dennis, S. J. (2021). The fallacy of an airtight alibi: Understanding human memory for “where” using experience sampling. Psychological Science, 32(6), 944–951. https://doi.org/10.1177/0956797620980752
 

Hyungwook Yim is an Assistant Professor in the Department of Cognitive Sciences at Hanyang University, Seoul, Korea. His research focuses on human learning and memory, and their development using computational models. 

Simon Dennis is a Professor in the School of Psychological Sciences, and the Director of the Complex Human Data Hub at the University of Melbourne, Australia. He is also the CEO of Unforgettable Research Services Pty Ltd. His research utilizes large scale real world data, experimental paradigms and computational modelling techniques to investigate the cognitive architecture underlying memory and language. 

 

Tags: 
memory
judgment/decision-making
law

About our Blog

Why is this blog called Character & Context?

Everything that people think, feel, and do is affected by some combination of their personal characteristics and features of the social context they are in at the time. Character & Context explores the latest insights about human behavior from research in personality and social psychology, the scientific field that studies the causes of everyday behaviors.  

□Learn More
□Contribute a Blog to Character & Context

Search the Blog

Get Email Updates from the Blog

Click below to join the Character & Context mailing list.
Subscribe

Popular Articles

Why You Should (Not) Stop Thinking About Work While at Home
Choosing to Be With Other People Matters More to Well-being Than Choosing to Be Alone
The Magical Aura of Insurance
Perceptions of People With Mental Illness as Sexually Exploitable
Finding Your Flow

Share this page
 
Society for Personality and Social Psychology
1120 Connecticut Ave NW, Suite 280
Washington, DC 20036
(202) 869-3240
info@spsp.org
Facebook Icon Twitter Icon LinkedIn Icon
  • Connect!
  • Join/Login
  • Home
  • About
  • Members
  • Publications
  • Events
  • Giving
  • Awards/Grants
  • News
  • Resources
  • Careers
© 2022. Society for Personality and Social Psychology®. All rights reserved.

View our Privacy Policy here.